I've been researching double strollers lately - still haven't made up my mind yet - and there are sooo many options out there! I know a few of my friends are looking for these too, so I thought I'd put on here what I've found and you can see how your needs compare to mine and which one will work best for you! My daughter will be 18 months when new baby arrives so we need something that will accommodate both of them very well.
Needs:
2 reclining seats - I'm sure both of my lo's will be wanting to take naps at some point. They don't have to completely recline but at least some sort of recline
Compatible with Chicco 30 carseat - already have this carseat from baby #1 so going to reuse & being due in October it could be pretty chilly here in Nebraska so I will probably leave baby in the carseat if I'm out and about
Tandem style - fits through doorways better, I'm just use to it because it's what my brother & sister-in-law had, the side-by-side feels uncomfortable & awkward to push to me
Cup holders/child tray - Need a place to put lo's snacks
Adjustable parent handlebars - my husband and I are both tall so we need to be able to put the bars up so it's comfortable for us but it would also be nice for the shorter grandma's to be able to push it comfortably too
Nice to have:
Parent tray with cup holders
Bigger basket underneath
Lightweight
Not super long - I don't want to be pushing around a bus
Here's a few I've been debating about and how they stack up.
Needs:
2 reclining seats - full recline in rear
Compatible with Chicco 30 carseat - yes
Tandem style - yes
Cup holders/child tray - cup holders in front only or arm bar
Adjustable parent handlebars - yes
Nice to have:
Parent tray with cup holders: Yes
Bigger basket underneath: yes but hard to access with backseat reclined or infant seat clicked in
Lightweight: 34 lbs
Not super long: 47.25" x 23.5" x 45.5"
Other to consider:
Seat weight limits: up to 40 lbs each seat
Double leg rests: yes-adjustable
NOTES: Might have to remove front canopy to fit in smaller vehicles. I tried this in the store and it seemed really long but that was compared to the Graco Ready to Grow stroller which is smaller (rear seat always faces backwards in that stroller) I love my Chicco Cortina single stroller - it rolls much better than any Graco I've ever used and I'm sad to give it up, so I'm hoping to love this one but, at the beginning of my research, it seems long...
__________________________________________________________
Needs:
2 reclining seats - Yes, rear fully reclines
Compatible with Chicco 30 carseat - NO
Tandem style - yes
Cup holders/child tray - Yes both seats
Adjustable parent handlebars - I don't believe so - says multiple hand positions...
Nice to have:
Parent tray with cup holders: Yes
Bigger basket underneath: Yes
Lightweight: 46.4 lbs
Not super long: 40 x 22.3 x 44
Other to consider:
Seat weight limits: front: 50 lbs, rear: 40 lbs
Double leg rests: yes
NOTES: Says 20% s
maller when folded as compared to Graco DuoGlider Stroller. Listed as Best Tandem Style Double Stroller on consumersearch.com.
__________________________________________________________
Needs:
2 reclining seats - Yes, rear seat removes to become sit n stand for older child
Compatible with Chicco 30 carseat - NO
Tandem style - yes
Cup holders/child tray - Yes both seats
Adjustable parent handlebars - NO
Nice to have:
Parent tray with cup holders: Yes
Bigger basket underneath: Yes
Lightweight: 32.5 lbs
Not super long: 43.0 " H x 21.5 " W x 49.0 " D, collapsed: 43.5 " H x 17.0 " D
Other to consider:
Seat weight limits: front: 40 lbs, jumpseat: 2 1/2 to 40 lbs
Double leg rests: yes
NOTES: Foot activated brake. I like that this has the sit n stand feature for later on when your toddler wants to get out and about and be more independent.
__________________________________________________________
Needs:
2 reclining seats - Yes - front can't recline with infant seat in back
Compatible with Chicco 30 carseat - Yes
Tandem style - yes
Cup holders/child tray - Yes both seats
Adjustable parent handlebars - Yes - 3 height positions
Nice to have:
Parent tray with cup holders: Just 1 cupholder - no tray
Bigger basket underneath: Yes
Lightweight: 43.6 lbs
Not super long: 34.5 x 20.2 x 13.2
Other to consider:
Seat weight limits: both up to 40 lbs
Double leg rests: yes - not adjustable
NOTES: Bright color is only color option.
Hopefully that helps you a little on what you might want to consider. Here is a link to the Consumer Reports stroller buying guide for tips on what to look for when purchasing.